THE TORAH ordains that every able-bodied Jew must make a
pilgrimage to the Temple of God on the Three Festivals.
"Three times in the year shall everyone of the males appear
before the Lord, thy God . . . No one shall appear before
the Lord empty. Every man according to what his hand can give,
according to the blessing of the Lord thy God which He hath
given thee" (Deut. 16:16-17).
Our sages say that certain individuals are absolved from
making that pilgrimage. I will mention only three notable
categories which are excluded from this command because of
certain defects in their personalities and attitudes.
Suma be'achat me'enav. One who is blind in
one eye is patur from coming to the Temple of God.
He who is afflicted with a one-sided view of life is unfit
to perceive and grasp either the sacred majesty of the
Bet Hamikdash or the inspiration of the holiday
spirit.
There are those who are either over-optimistic or
unduly pessimistic about Judaism. In either case they
have a wrong and one-sided view of life. They are
sumim be'achhat me'enehem. They have a deficiency
in one of their eyes. I have known people who when
observing the flurry of religious activity before and
during the High Holidays are so carried away with
enthusiasm that they break out in a paean of song.
When they witness the rush to the cemeteries and the
packed Synagogues they feel certain that everything
is just fine in Jewish life. They see only one side
of the picture and refuse to look at the other side.
They do not stop to consider what is happening to our
Synagogues throughout the remainder of the year.
And so they go home rekam -empty. They make
no resolve to work for Jewish education, for Torah or
for the Shule because, they say, everything is
getting along famously without them. They point to the
great outpouring of men and women on Rosh Hashana and
Yom Kippur, and they say, "Judaism is on the upswing
and there is nothing to worry about!"
There are others whose defective vision is in the
opposite direction. They are the great pessimists
who see only the seamy side and the shady spots of life.
They are the Calamity Janes and Ikes of our people.
They point, almost with glee, to the abysmal ignorance
and the religious indifference that pervades the
Jewish scene, and they clasp their hands and say
that it's no use! There is nothing to be done because
nothing will help. Judaism, according to them, is galloping
like a blind horse downhill and will soon crash and die.
They consider the High Holiday Jew a hypocrite and his
enthusiasm a sham and a farce.
Such people also return rekam-empty from
the House of God. For if everything is lost, why should
they bother to help? What's the sense of working for
a lost cause? Their onesided and deficient view provides them
with an easy excuse for doing nothing.
The sages advised such a man to stay home, so as not to
contaminate the other people with his pessimistic and
destructive views.
Only those who have a good and balanced view - who can
see with both eyes the good and the bad, the clouds and
the sunshine - are urged to make the pilgrimage to the
House of God. Such men and women have built Synagogues,
Talmud Torahs and Yeshivas in America in the past, and are
continuing to support them in the present. Such men and
women have drained the swamps and invested their fortunes
in Israel for decades, and are continuing their devoted
service to the Holy Land to this very day.
A second category that is incapable of deriving any
substantial benefit from a visit to the Temple is the
chiger, the one who limps, a person who is
nebech, lame or crippled.
I am sorry to have to say it, but you know that this is
true. We have among us people who are evolving a religion
of chigrim, of spiritual cripples,
hinkedike yiddishkeit.
Their entire philosophy and approach to Judaism is crippled.
If it weren't our own tzarah it would be laughable.
Consider for example the ads in The New York Times,
and New York Post. Before the High Holidays several
hotels advertise that divine services will be conducted by a
prominent Cantor and Choir, and that shrimps and lobsters
will be served. A Cantor with shrimps and a choir with
lobsters - if that is not crippled Judaism, what is?
Then there are so-called siddurim, prayer books,
which declare in their introduction that since God and
Nature are one, God cannot answer prayer. What need is
there for a Siddur? And the answer is: to satisfy
the yearning of man to commune in the company of other
people with a mystical force. If that is not lame thinking,
what is?
Our sages, therefore, ruled that one who is so afflicted,
need not make the pilgrimage, for he will return rekam,
emptyhanded, anyway.
The third is, "He who is unable to go up on his own feet."
Here our rabbis have touched upon one of the most vulnerable
spots in our lives. Until recently American Israel lived on
the spiritual resources of European Jewry. The new immigrants
who came here after the First and Second World Wars have
injected new virility and spiritual strength into our
communities. Rabbis, scholars, teachers, books, religious
articles were supplied to us me'ever la yam, from
across the ocean. Time and tragic events have changed the
picture today, and the American Jew must learn the art of
laalot beraglav, to stand on his own two feet.
He must produce all these things himself. He must become
spiritually self-sufficient and religiously self-sustaining.
There are those who speak glibly of the pious parents and
grandparents they had. They show you their pictures and their
old and worn prayer books and prayer shawls. But all this
has no connection with their own personal lives. As far as
they are concerned they are items that rightfully belong
to a museum. And the question I ask is: how long can a religion
thrive if it is dependent only on the yerushah of our
forebears - if we treat these cherished religious items as
museum pieces, if we view our forebears as having belonged
to some fantastic world - far beyond our reach or interest?
The plea of our sages is that we strive to make the religion
of our fathers our own. Only thus can we purge ourselves of
moral paralysis - of not being able to be spiritually
independent and self-sustaining.